Showing posts with label market timing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label market timing. Show all posts

8/25/19

The End is Nigh? 2020 Recession?



There's a lot of talk lately about a recession in 2020. What's all the fuss about?

Reasons Why A Recession Might Happen in 2020

We're Overdue for a Recession

The United States has not had a recession in over 10 years, the last one having ended in June 2009. Since 1900, the average time between recessions has been just under four years. Since the end of World War II, the average time between recessions has been around five years. With the longest time between recessions having been 10 years (from March 1991 to March 2001, when the Dot Com bubble burst), it looks like we're overdue for a recession. Some experts even say we're already in one.

Consumers are Overleveraged

Before the last recession, aka The Great Recession or The Financial Crisis, there were luxury sedans, mostly BMWs and Mercedes Benzes, everywhere. I couldn't believe so many people could afford to drive those cars. There were also ads on TV by dubious loan providers where the actor would say how great his life was despite being in debt up to his eyeballs.

Fast forward to today, and I see Infinitis and Lexuses everywhere. While I stopped watching TV completely (one of the most positive changes in my life), I have been made aware of new consumer debt products. There are now payment plans for vacations. People who can't afford vacations and thus should not be going on any are borrowing from companies like Funjet, Bookit, and UpLift for their trips. I suppose that's better than putting the trip on the credit card, but it's easy to see how this spells doom in the future.

Credit card companies are also introducing lay away type options (but you get the thing you want immediately--where would we be without instant gratification?). For example, American Express has something called Plan It, where you can buy a bunch of stuff you don't really need and certainly can't afford, and then for a set fee, you make monthly payments on it. It's just another way of collecting interest (which might be worthwhile for people that carry credit card balances if the set fee is lower than the interest they would've paid).

The Yield Curve is Inverted

The Treasury bond yield curve is a chart of yields that are currently paid by Treasury bonds of various maturities.

In a normal yield curve, shorter term bonds have lower yields than longer term bonds, so the curve ascends from the shorter maturities on the bottom left to the longer maturities on the upper right. This is normal because there is less interest rate risk with shorter maturity bonds than with longer term ones, so bond investors usually demand less return for shorter maturity bonds than longer term ones.

In an inverted yield curve, on the other hand, shorter maturity bonds have higher yields than longer term bonds. This happens when there is greater demand for longer term maturities than shorter ones. It is an indication that bond investors anticipate bond yields will go down. Yield inversions have often preceded recessions by six to 24 months. Since 1955, an inverted yield curve predicted all nine US recessions.

Trump's Trade Wars

President Trump has been imposing tariffs on various foreign goods. Whether you agree with the policy or not, a tariff is a tax on the product on which it is levied. Taxes are pretty much never borne by the producer of the product that is taxed. The tax is usually passed off on the last seller or the end buyer. This raises the cost of the product (which is what a tariff is supposed to do--raise prices of foreign products to encourage people to buy from a domestic producer instead). With the cost of products going up, retailers will have smaller profit margins and/or consumers will ultimately have less to spend, which might decrease economic output and thus contribute to a recession.


Reasons Why A Recession Might Not Happen in 2020

Firstly, everyone's talking about it.

2020 Recession videos on Youtube are suddenly about as ubiquitous as those with people making stupid faces on the cover. Indeed, many of the 2020 recession videos have people making stupid faces. Traditional media is also hyping up the possibility of a 2020 recession, dragging out everyone and anyone who thinks there will be one. This is because doomsday news sells better and it makes Trump look bad.

Unless they make it into a self-fulfilling prophesy, all this hoopla may indicate that a recession won't happen. Regular people and the experts for whom the mainstream media provides a platform have a notoriously bad record at predicting the future, especially future economic events. When the regular people are discussing the economy and future, it's often profitable to do the opposite of what they're doing.

Second, there are no rules for how long it should be between recessions. Since the Great Depression, the time between recessions has ranged from as little as one year to the current 10 years and counting. The recession that started in July 1981 didn't care that it had only been one year since the recession that ended in July 1980. Likewise, the next recession doesn't care how long it's been since the last one.

Additionally, our data set is quite small and today's economy is not the same as that of the past. To say that we're overdue for a recession implies that the future will be like the past. It may very well be, but we can't know that until it happens.

The inverted yield curve predicting all nine recessions since 1955 may sound scary, but does it even mean anything? We know with near 100% certainty that there will be a recession in the future. There's a chance that the economy will continue growing in perpetuity, but that is unlikely. So, an inverted yield curve will always predict the next recession. Why? Because the yield curve is inverted and at some point in the future we will surely have a recession. That's like me predicting that you will die. I'm hardly a psychic, but my prediction will come true. The trick is to get the timing right.

So when, according to the inverted yield curve, is the next recession due? From six to 24 months. That's quite a range. I bet, if the next recession comes 36 months after the inversion, future financial news articles will be about how an inverted yield curve presages a recession by 6 to 36 months.

Conclusion

There may or may not be a recession in 2020. We might be in a recession already. No one knows. I repeat, no one knows.

The way you invest should not change according to the economic forecast. You have nothing to gain from trying to time the market. People have been waiting for the economy to collapse for years now. Let me repeat again, no one knows the future.

That said, always be prepared. Whether the economic outlook is rosy or grey, you should always have an emergency fund and you shouldn't be investing if you don't have one. You should always be updating your skills to stay competitive in the marketplace. You should never be buying things you don't need and can't afford. And you should never take risks with money you can't afford to lose.

Finally, never worry about things you can't control. As long as you're always prepared, you will always be as ready as you'll ever be, so why worry?

1/27/08

Why (Financial) Stocks Should Head Lower

It looks like there will be trouble in the Credit Default Swap market.

Credit Default Swaps are used to transfer credit exposure of fixed income instruments, such as mortgages and bonds, between parties, to spread risk. It works in the following way. One party buys protection on a debt instrument from another party, the seller, who guarantees the credit worthiness of the debt instrument. If the instrument, let's say a corporate bond, defaults in its interest payments, for example if the company that issued the bond goes out of business, the seller of the credit default swap is supposed to reimburse the buyer. Basically, Credit Default Swaps are insurance on fixed income securities that holders buy to limit their risk. We can call Credit Default Swap sellers insurers.

The combined value of all Credit Default Swaps is somewhere around $450 trillion, but this includes lots of reselling. That is, the same default swaps have been sold multiple times. The actual value of the Credit Default swap market is in the range of $27 to $90 trillion. For perspective, note that the size of the US economy was around $12 trillion, as of July, 2007.

So what's the problem, and what does it have to do with stocks?

In the Credit Default Swap market, it's really difficult to determine who owns what. As defaults rise, and Standard & Poors estimates the default rate will go up to 3.4% by the fourth quarter of this year (up from the current 2.6%), and it turns out that some sellers cannot reimburse the buyers, a panic may ensue. The market may freeze up because no one really knows who holds what.

Why would swap sellers be unable to reimburse buyers if buyers' bonds default? Because some (maybe most) sellers have sold much more insurance than they have in assets. Imagine a seller with $500 million in assets selling $5 billion worth of insurance. Should those bonds default, the seller can't possibly pay for all of them. It will go out of business, leaving the buyer in a bind.

As one example, this is just happened with Merrill Lynch (MER) recently. Of the $11.5 billion in bad debt that the investment bank wrote down in its last quarterly report, around $3 billion was credit default swaps Merrill Lynch bought from ACA Capital (which was AAA-rated, but sold $60 billion in insurance while its assets were only $500 million!). So, Merrill Lynch wasted its money buying insurance because it was left unprotected. Lehman Brothers (LEH) and Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce (CM) have experienced a similar problem. All indications point to it happening again with other buyers of Credit Default Swaps. The upshot is that the Credit Default Swap market could dry up, for why should buyers pay for something that could be essentially worthless? Keep in mind that the Credit Default Swap market is a lot bigger than sub-prime mortgages.

Another thing to note is that in addition to being buyers of Credit Default Swaps, banks and hedge funds are also sellers. That is, they are also insurers. No one but them knows how much they have sold. Default rates, until recently, have been at historic lows. It's entirely possible that banks could have sold much more insurance than they have in assets.

Bill Gross of PIMCO has said not too long ago that the typical default rate during recessions is 1.25%. This is around $250 billion dollars. (Note that S&P's figure, mentioned above, is much higher.) Insurers will be driven into bankruptcy and/or buyers of Credit Default Swaps will be left unprotected, also possibly driven into bankruptcy. Either way, someone will lose a lot of money, and this could trigger a chain of defaults that might not stop until the over leverage (e.g. what ACA Capital did) is worked out of the system. There will be lots of fear, and stocks should head lower.

Of course, no one really knows what stocks will do. Another large Fed rate cut could send stocks much higher (this would be an excellent time to buy an inverse ETF, in my opinion) or it could spook investors into selling everything, potentially making some bargains in unrelated industries, like my favorite, tobacco.

Just an example of how near term market activity can be premature/irrational: UBS had reported huge sub-prime related losses before the market opened at the end of October, 2007. If I had enough money and was brave enough, I would have shorted it. The next day, when the market opened, I was surprised to see that the stock was going up. The explanation was that with its losses revealed, all the bank's problems were behind it. How fortunate, I thought then, that I didn't short it. UBS was trading in the low to mid $50s then. As of last market close, it was $41.62, about 20% lower.

If the markets go up in the near term, it will be on unfounded optimism. I am firmly convinced, as I was last October, that the debt crisis is far from over. Nothing has been resolved with the sub-prime mortgages. Home prices are still falling around the country, and are just now starting to fall in NY. The inventory of new homes is large enough to have home prices fall some more. As collateralized debt obligation holders find that their sub-prime mortgages continue to default, and as the recession progresses and corporations begin defaulting on their bonds, the Credit Default Swap market, which is over leveraged, will have problems of its own. I'm not a near term trader, nor do I make buy and sell recommendations (or at least I try not to) but I would ask you to consider selling during market rallies, or at least not buying during them, until hope is finally squashed and the market is less volatile.

1/20/08

If You Must Time the Market, Buy Only When Fear Takes Hold

Repeated so many times it's become a cliche, I'm sure you heard this one of Warren Buffet's famous aphorisms: be fearful when others are greedy and greedy only when others are fearful.

It makes a lot of sense. That's how you buy stocks, and anything really, on the cheap.

So why don't people do it? Why do the majority of retail investors lose money on the stock market?


Small individual investors are fearful when times are bad, or are about to be bad--during a recession or when it seems there will be one. At such uncertain times, when you don't know how long your job will last, when there are no other job prospects in sight, and when the cost of your daily living goes steadily up all the while what stock holdings you've been able to amass plummet, it's hard not to be fearful. Putting money away for emergency use becomes much more important. Investing, if not a faraway thought, seems imprudent at such times. And rightly so.



For those with money to spare, however, fortunes can be made. All sorts of assets get cheaper, from stocks to land. They will eventually go up; history shows us this. For example, the Dow Jones Industrial Average nearly quadrupled from mid 1932 to 1937, after the great crash. Following every market downturn, stocks have broken even and then gone higher. Buying near the bottom, when others were fearful, has always paid off quite well.



It may come as no surprise that small individual investors rarely come out ahead after a market and economic downturn. Part of it is because of what's mentioned above--the fear. Part of it, however, comes from not following the other side of Buffet's advice: being fearful when others are greedy; and it is being greedy when others are greedy that causes the fear. For instance, it is somewhat common knowledge that an easy way to determine when the market has reached its peak is when individual investors enter the market. This is when one should become fearful.



It is said that that John F. Kennedy's father sold all his stocks before the great crash because he overheard shoeshine boys discussing stocks. From my own experience, when I was a wee lad during the height of the late 1990s internet bubble, one of my dad's acquaintances, a regular Joe, started talking about buying stocks, emphatically saying, "we have to buy those things--you know, those papers--stocks!" At the same time, the talking heads on CNBC were screaming that there was no top in sight. If you were watching CNBC in October when the DJIA reached its record high, you might remember the talking heads screaming that that was the bottom, and the sky's the limit. That's when you should cash out.



When should you start buying? When your uncle Charlie's lamenting about his stock market losses starts getting on your nerves, the screamers on TV are quiet and gray faced, and politicians have been talking about stimulus packages for a while. That's it. Don't buy at any other time. Save the money you would have used to buy stocks at their highs in an interest bearing account. Be patient. So you'll feel a little left out when the TV screamers are jolly, but you'll have money to spare when things are cheap.



Will you do it? No. Will I? No.

The temptation to buy when things are good is too great.

1/18/08

International & Domestic Inverse/Bear Market ETFs

If you think the markets will continue their decline, you might want to consider inverse ETFs. Some of these have become somewhat popular, so maybe you heard of them. But you probably haven't heard of all of them.

Inverse ETFs use various derivatives to behave in the opposite way of their underlying indexes. For instance, the inverse Dow 30 ETF (DOG) does the opposite of what the Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA) does. For example, if the DJIA falls 1.5%, DOG will rise by about 1.5%. The correlation is not perfect, but it's close.

An advantage of using inverse ETFs is that you can hold a short position while going long. In other words, it's like holding a regular stock, but you profit as if you have sold short. As there is no need for a margin account to do this, you are mitigating or eliminating some of the risks of selling short, which include losing more than your original investment.

If you're a bit more risk tolerant, you might want to consider leveraged inverse ETFs. Like the regular inverse ETFs, they go up when their underlying index goes down, but they do so twice as much. So, for example, if the DJIA falls 1.5%, the leveraged inverse ETF (DXD) will go up about 3%.

One last thing before the list. You should remember that inverse ETFs go down when the market goes up, and the leveraged ones go down twice as much. As over the long term the market tends to go up, it's probably best to use inverse ETFs to hedge your loses in rough times or for short term gains.

Here's the list. Some of them are thinly traded, so be careful. The expense ratios on all these ETFs are .95%. Unsurprisingly, they are all at or near 52 week highs.


Inverse International ETFs

Europe Australia Far East (EFZ)
Emerging Markets (EUM)

Leveraged Inverse International ETFs

FTSE/Xinhua China (FXP)
Europe Australia Far East (EFU)
Emerging Markets (EEV)
Japan (EWV)

Inverse Domestic Broad Indexes:

Nasdaq-100 (PSQ)
DJIA (DOG)
S&P 500 (SH)
S&P MidCap (MYY)
S&P SmallCap (SBB)
Russell2000 (RWM)

Leveraged Domestic Indexes:

Nasdaq-100 (QID)
DJIA (DXD)
S&P 500 (SDS)
S&P MidCap (MZZ)
S&P SmallCap (SDD)
Russell 2000 (TWM)
Russell 1000 Value (SJF)
Russell 1000 Growth (SFK)
Russell MidCap Value (SJL)
Russell MidCap Growth (SDK)
Russell 2000 Value (SJH)
Russell 2000 Growth (SKK)

Leveraged Inverse Domestic Sector ETFs

Dow Jones U.S. Basic Materials (SMN)
Dow Jones U.S. Consumer Goods (SCC)
Dow Jones U.S. Financials (SKF)
Dow Jones U.S. Health Care (RXD)
Dow Jones U.S. Industrials (SIJ)
Dow Jones U.S. Real Estate (SRS)
Dow Jones U.S. Semiconductors (SSG)
Dow Jones U.S. Oil & Gas (DUG)
Dow Jones U.S. Technology (REW)
Dow Jones U.S. Utilities (SDP)


European investors might be interested in these:

Inverse CAC 40

Leveraged Inverse CAC 40

Inverse DJ Euro Stoxx 50

Leveraged Inverse DJ Euro Stoxx 50